🧠 Why Does Increased “Intelligence” Sometimes Lead to More Issues in ESS?
“Smart” or “Intelligent” is a buzzword in the energy storage industry. However, field experience often shows a counter-intuitive phenomenon: the more complex the system, the more potential problems arise.
I. Intelligence Does Not Equal Stability
Adding complexity through advanced algorithms often creates instability and operational challenges.
-
Algorithm Logic Is Hard to Verify: Complex control algorithms are difficult to test across all possible operational scenarios. Subtle logic flaws may only appear under rare, specific field conditions.
-
Abnormal States Are Inexplicable: When an intelligent system fails, the root cause is often obscure. The opaque decision-making process hinders quick troubleshooting.
-
Operators Cannot Intervene: Highly automated systems sometimes restrict human access to core controls. Operators struggle to diagnose or override faulty automation during emergencies.
II. What Engineers Value More Than “Smart”
For system engineers, reliability and controllability are paramount over sophisticated algorithms. They prioritize system behavior that is transparent and manageable.
-
Predictable Behavior: The system’s response to expected inputs must be consistent and known. Predictability ensures operational safety and reliability.
-
Traceable Status (Auditability): Every action and state change must be logged and linked back to a specific command. This ensures effective post-incident analysis.
-
Revertible Anomalies (Rollback Capability): The system must allow safe, immediate restoration to a previously stable state. This minimizes downtime during control failures.
III. Imax Power’s Engineering Philosophy
In Imax Power’s Energy Storage System Solutions, intelligence is conditional. Automation must always serve the goal of controllability.
The premise is clear: Any autonomous behavior must allow for human comprehension and manual takeover. This ensures safety and control even when complex algorithms fail.
IV. Conclusion
The benchmark for a good energy storage system is maximum controllability, not necessarily maximum intelligence. Reliability stems from simplicity and transparency.
